The 3 Judges gave different versions and finally in summary
· All agreed that the core disputed site be given to Hindus
· 2 of them agreed that original temple was demolished by Babar, while the third say that the Masjid was built on the ruins of Temple – but by not demolishing.
· 2 of then agreed that it is the birth place of Ram as per the faith and belief.
· None wanted to accept the report the very much genuine ASI report
Justice Sharma the outgoing Judge whose last date is 1st Oct in service – has said that
· The Masjid was built against the norms and principles of Muslim by demolishing another religious shrine, having images of other religious Gods, not doing any Namaz for many years
· He firmly beliefs that the core place is the birth place of Ram
· The entire site be given to Rama Janmabhoomi trust
Justice Agrawal and Khan are of the opinion that since Sunni wakf board and Nimohi Akhara are involved in this case from day-one and are actively involved since 60 years – be given equal rights to the land.
Thus it became one third each to the 3 groups (giving resemblance to a Monkey sharing the Roti to cats equally and thus swallowing finally)
The Judgment may not be a surprise one – but more of a balancing act like politicians.
The judges wanted to be safe and did not want to be dragged into controversy. Not sure if they wanted to really solve or just to pass on the buck to next levels.
In any case let us see how each one have reacted conveniently to their advantage and politicians started to take sides.
· Hindu Mahasabha wants to go to SC for claiming the entire site
· Sunni wakf board also wants to go for the SC as they do not want to surrender the 2/3rd of their original land.
· Only Nimohi.. has not shown much disagreement as of now
· RSS welcomed – but silent on if they are OK for Masjid to be constructed adjacent to Ram temple (hints are they do not want).
· VHP – officially not yet given statement – but very clear through Mahasabha that they want to go to SC
· BJP welcomed like RSS – but do not want a Masjid adjacent to Temple.
· Congress
o Was not happy with the judgment as it has given edge to BJP – which stood and fought for Rama Janmabhoomi.
o That’s why before other parties said anything – the spokespersons, PM, HM .. all said that this is not final and to wait for SC. There is no need for them to give such nasty statements when they are not a party in the case.
o Chidamabaram – said that this case no way weakens Babri demolition case
§ This is also again an absurd statement. Not relevant at this time.
§ This is just to expose their pseudo-secularism stand and to woo Muslims
§ This Judgment definitely will have a bearing on Demolition case – as Pro-Hindu groups case has been vindicated
· Mulayam and Mayawathi are afraid of their current status and saying that the judgment is hurting Muslims – before even the other Muslim organizations are expressing their views.
· Communists as usual were caught unaware – what to comment.
· The TV channels – NDTV, CNN-IBN, TimesNow – are coming with a new proposition that why cannot an all religion structure be built there?
o These so called Pseudo secular channels will be happy to instigate violence in the country
o While the fight is between Hindu and Muslim groups – they want to join other religions also into this
o They are coining Masjid construction while no other Muslim organizations are yet talking about this.
o They should know how to behave on such sensitive issues – I do not think they will learn in their life time – they talk rubbish in the name of moderates
Anyhow – Muslim groups will go to SC in 3 months, it will take a year, then the final bench will take another year, then for Land sharing – new cases will be filed – it will take 2 to 3 years. So there is no surprise that in total it may take 5 to 10 years for final settlement.
As long as all the groups abide for this snail court processing and the final Judgment – no issues to any Indians.
No comments:
Post a Comment